
After all the hype and months of waiting, the much anticipated Coreplayer is finally here. But do we really need it? Do we even need a video player? Here are a few reasons against Coreplayer.
1)First of all, almost every power user I know already has Smartmovie, so do we really need another video player?
2) Phones like the N80 and older promised native MPEG4 playback, but fell short do to their inability to playback H.264 AVC (MPEG-4 Part 10), that’s why many users looked for players like Smartmovie. The situation has changed so much that current phones like the N93, N93i and N95 all can playback H.264 AVC without a problem. Add the fact that there are many free converters like SUPER that can easily convert just about any video into formats like H.264 AVC or even MPEG-4, H.263/3GPP and RealVideo 8/9/10. All of these formats are natively supported by the built-in Real Player.
3)The Real Player has gotten really good. I’ve noticed that it copes well with even 640x480 video. This is expected since the latest phones like N95 and N93 all capture VGA (640X480) video and it naturally supports this resolution. While the controls could be better, it offers all the basics like forward, rewind and pause.
4)Coreplayer is known for it’s support for many audio and video formats. But again Smartmovie has an included converter, making it able to convert and play any video you want. Obviously you need to convert the videos first, but it can atleast do. Also, as stated above, converters like Super are free and can convert just about any format out there. So why is Coreplayer so special?
5)After finally releasing Coreplayer we get to buy a BETA product? There isn’t even a way to try the app first before buying.
On the other side, players like Coreplayer and Smartmovie do offer a better experience and many more features, but I can’t argue with the fact that the built-in Real Player is free. Combined with Super it does what it needs to do: play videos! Only thing that can change my mind right now is native Windows Media Video and FLV Playback. In the mean time things aren’t looking so good for Coreplayer.
Update:Apparently a demo version will come, but Late Q1 of 08. And about the Windows Media support, the guys at Coreplayer are indicating that the first Beta 1 release will only support WMA. After Beta 1 they will add the WMV decoder. They are also noting that it’s very, very slow and that they plan on adding their own WMV decoder by version 1.3. As for the FLV support they are saying: “no player outside of Adobe Flash Player plays Flash unless Adobe has blessed/licensed it to them. While we internally DO support the Flash 'container' and the codecs within it (ON2, H.263, H.264/CoreAVC). We only have this available to our OEM customers that may have a direct license with Adobe and cannot release it in our consumer editions of CorePlayer Mobile or CorePlayer Professional.” This seems to solve a few things, but these are all “planned” things and we know how much these things take, especially if the delayed launch is any indication. It is starting to look better for them, but I will just have to wait and see. Until then Smartmovie is my choice.